By Michael Kennedy 
When it comes to replacing your roof, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is choosing the right material. For most homeowners, the choice comes down to metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles. Both are popular, reliable options — but they come with very different price points, performance traits, and long-term value.
So which one is right for you?
In this guide, we’ll compare metal roofs and shingles across key factors like durability, cost, maintenance, energy efficiency, curb appeal, and climate performance — so you can make the smartest investment for your home.
Asphalt Shingles
The most common roofing material in the U.S. Affordable, easy to install, and available in a variety of styles and colors. Typically made from a fiberglass base with asphalt coating and protective granules.
Metal Roofing
Made from steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper, either in panels or shingles. Known for superior durability and a modern look. Available as standing seam panels or metal shingles designed to mimic traditional styles.
Metal Roof:
- Lifespan: 40–70 years
- Resistant to fire, wind, mildew, insects, and rot
- Handles extreme weather well (hail, snow, heat)
- Doesn’t crack, warp, or deteriorate like other materials
- Color may fade slightly over time
Shingles:
- Lifespan: 15–30 years (depending on quality)
- Prone to curling, cracking, and blow-off in storms
- Vulnerable to algae, moss, and water retention
- More frequent repairs or replacements are common
Verdict: Metal roofs are the clear winner for long-term durability.
Installation Cost per Sq. Ft.:
- Metal: $8–$14
- Shingles: $3–$7
Total Replacement Cost (Average Home):
- Metal Roof: $12,000–$25,000+
- Shingle Roof: $7,000–$12,000
Long-Term Value:
- Metal costs more upfront, but lasts 2–3x longer
- Shingles are cheaper to install but may require replacement sooner
Verdict: Asphalt shingles are budget-friendly in the short term, while metal roofs pay off long-term.
Metal Roofs:
- Minimal maintenance
- Occasional inspections for shifting panels or fastener wear
- May need resealing or repainting after 30–40 years
Shingles:
- Requires regular inspections
- Susceptible to missing, cracked, or curling shingles
- More prone to granule loss and moss buildup
- Gutter maintenance is essential to prevent backup damage
Verdict: Metal roofs require far less maintenance.
Metal Roofing:
- Reflects solar radiant heat
- Can lower cooling costs by 10–25%
- Often made with recycled materials and is fully recyclable
Shingles:
- Absorb more heat, increasing indoor temps
- Some cool-roof shingles exist but are less efficient than metal
- Shorter lifespan reduces sustainability
Verdict: Metal roofing wins for energy efficiency and environmental impact.
Hot, Sunny Climates:
Metal reflects heat and resists UV damage
Cold, Snowy Regions:
Metal sheds snow easily, reducing ice damming
Storm-Prone Areas:
Metal withstands winds up to 140+ mph
Humid or Coastal Zones:
Aluminum and coated metals resist rust better than shingles
Verdict: Metal roofing excels in all climates.
Metal Roofs:
- Sleek, modern look
- Comes in various colors and textures
- Available styles mimic shingles, tile, or slate
- Often adds to home resale appeal
Shingles:
- Classic, traditional appearance
- Available in a wide variety of colors and textures
- HOA-friendly and fits into most neighborhoods seamlessly
Verdict: Metal is bold and modern; shingles are classic and versatile — choose based on your style.
Many HOAs default to approving asphalt shingles due to their traditional appearance. Metal roofs are increasingly popular but may require special approval based on color, sheen, or panel style.
Pro Tip: Always check with your HOA or local council before installing a metal roof — especially in planned communities or historic districts.
According to national data:
- Metal roofing offers better resale value due to longevity, modern aesthetics, and energy efficiency
- Shingle roofs are still widely accepted but may be viewed as shorter-term solutions
Buyers in regions with harsh weather or extreme temperatures often see a metal roof as a premium upgrade.
Choose Metal Roofing If:
- You plan to stay in your home long-term
- You live in an area with high wind, hail, or snow
- You value durability, energy savings, and reduced maintenance
- You’re prepared for a higher upfront investment
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
- You’re on a tighter renovation budget
- You prefer a more traditional or neutral aesthetic
- You may sell or move within the next 10–15 years
- Your HOA restricts material choices
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the metal roof vs. shingles debate — it depends on your priorities, location, and how long you plan to live in your home. Metal roofs offer superior durability, energy efficiency, and weather resistance, while asphalt shingles remain a cost-effective, reliable option that fits nearly any neighborhood.
Before making your final decision, talk with a licensed roofing contractor. They’ll evaluate your home’s structure, your region’s climate, and your long-term plans — and help you choose the roofing system that makes the most sense for your lifestyle and budget.